Talk Derby to Me (1 Viewer)

vegasnitro

Nitro Member
It’s back!

From the guy who told you not to bet on Barbaro no matter what in 2006.
From the guy who told you not to bet on Street Sense no matter what in 2007.

It’s the complete idiot’s guide to handicapping the Kentucky Derby for 2008.

This year we have 2 horses you should NOT bet on no matter what. The first horse you should not bet on no matter what is the favorite, Big Brown. He drew the far outside post, gate 20. Only 1 horse in the 134 year history of the Derby has won from the 20 spot, and that occurred before the starting gate was invented back in the 1920s. He likes to run from the front, and the Derby is the 1 race that is impossible to go gate to wire, that stretch run at Churchill Downs is VERY LONG. Big Brown is going to have to make a much longer trip than horses inside of him if he is to win. Big Brown only has 3 career starts, and no horse since Regret 90+ years ago has won the Derby on so few starts. Lastly, he has not run since the Florida Derby, and if you throw out Barbaro, no horse has won the Derby in over 100 years on 5 weeks rest.

The second horse you should not bet on no matter what is the filly is Eight Belles. She is going to get some hype and some play, particularly since filly Rags to Riches won the Belmont last year. I will dispel the myth for you right now, Eight Belles is no where near the horse Rags to Riches is. Eight Belles would not even be the favorite if she was running with the rest of the fillies in the Kentucky Oaks on Friday, as Proud Spell has that field well covered. Only 3 fillies have ever won the Derby, and no filly that has never raced against the boys has ever won. This will be Eight Belles first run with the boys, and in the biggest race of the year? Save your money.

So who should you put your money on?

I like Pyro on top. He is the best athlete in the race. He can come from way back, he can rate the pace, he can run in the slop if it rains, he can run inside or outside, he doesn’t mind dirt in his face and he has run many big races against tough competition. He is ready to fire, and he is the third choice in the 6-1 or 7-1 range, so you are going to get a price.

Next up is Colonel John. The California shipper has finished first or second in all 6 starts. The only question mark is this will be his first race on dirt, he has only run on the California synthetic tracks. The Cal horses that have shipped east onto dirt have done very well, and this horse is remarkably consistent. Don’t leave this horse out of any exacta/trifecta/superfecta wagering. The only downside is he is the second choice at 4-1, so you are not going to fetch much of a price.

Next up is Z Fortune. Horse is constantly improving and is one of the few that has put up a triple digit Beyer speed figure. Has run second to Pyro, and Pyro had to run him down in an electrifying performance. He has turned in some very nice works at Churchill last week and appears to be fit and ready. Good news is he should be a HUGE price 15-1 or more.

From here the picture gets muddied. You can make a case for Gayego (another California polytrack shipper, bad post position though), Monba (horse for the course? Has won at Churchill before), Cool Coal Man (got the best of now-injured War Pass, has won at Churchill before), Court Vision (always seems to be in the money, but hasn’t won in a while), Smooth Air (same as Court Vision), and Adriano (has never beat anybody of note but jockey Edgar Prado passed on other horses to ride him). Any of these horses should be big prices, 12-1 or higher.

There is a lot of value in this year’s Derby, expect to see another $1,000 trifecta and $10,000 superfecta on Saturday, so play plenty of exotics, drink a mint julep or two and have fun!
 
Last edited:
Chris, I think you pretty much have it covered buddy. I started not to bet this year b/c the field is really wide open however I did place just a little bet on: PYRO. I agree with everything you said. My 2nd pick though would be Big Brown. I talked to a friend in Kentucky yesterday who's around the business and he swears BB is a bad hombre. 3 races, big layoff, we will see. And like you said, drawing gate 20 isint good. If he was 5 to 10 I might have picked him. And I dont think 8 Belles will be in the top 3 maybe not even the top 5. But we will see. I would love one day to go to the derby. I have been to Churchill Downs before but not for the derby. Its a beautiful place.
 
Due to circumstances beyond my control I am missing the Derby this year for the first time in YEARS. I will still be able to bet it at a sportsbook in Vegas, but it is not the same as walking up to a window at the Downs.

There are no more exciting words in the English language than "Down the stretch they come at the Kentucky Derby". Gives me goosebumps just thinking about it ....
 
Due to circumstances beyond my control I am missing the Derby this year for the first time in YEARS. I will still be able to bet it at a sportsbook in Vegas, but it is not the same as walking up to a window at the Downs.

There are no more exciting words in the English language than "Down the stretch they come at the Kentucky Derby". Gives me goosebumps just thinking about it ....

I agree, my wife and I love the KD. We watch it every year. We have a horse track by us and every year they have a hat contest, serve dinner and let you bet and watch the race and they sell out early but we arent going this year, just going to watch it from home.

What I think will happen is that BB is going to come out mid pack, charge to the lead and then about a mile he's going to poop out and start going backwards. I think 8 Belles is going to do the same thing, I think she will hang top 3 to top 5 until the mile and then she will be gone. Thats when Pyro will charge to the front.
 
Wow, talk about wierd; on the broadcast Bob Frey just mentioned that Doug Kalitta's company flew several horses to the derby.... after I JUST read this thread like 3 minutes before he said that, thinking I should post it here. LOL
But Doug; and Connie's company in earlier years, have been flying race horses for years and years. It's a rather lucrative market. Those animals can be in thier home barn at 8am, hop in the trailer.... be on a plane by 10.....hour & a half later they're getting into a trailer and on thier way to the track. They make the run, back in the trailer and on the plane and back home that evening for dinner!! Kalitta hauls horses for just about every "big" race in North America, certainly the Triple Crown venues. They've hauled rodeo livestock, too. Who knew, right???
 
Last edited:
Those animals can be in thier home barn at 8am, hop in the trailer.... be on a plane by 10.....hour & a half later they're getting into a trailer and on thier way to the track. They make the run, back in the trailer and on the plane and back home that evening for dinner!!

It's not quite this quick, but it's close. Kentucky requires all shipped-in horses to be quarantined for 24 hours. So in theory you could fly in a Derby horse on Friday morning, have him quarantined for the mandatory 24 hours, run the Derby Saturday afternoon and have him on the plane and home by Saturday night.

I am sticking with Pyro but this Derby is shaping up like the '05 Derby when Giacomo won at 50-1. Don't be afraid to take a shot on some of the longshots.

Also, if you paid close attention to my original post ... I gave you yesterday's Kentucky Oaks winner ... Proud Spell.
 
It’s back!

It’s the complete idiot’s guide to handicapping the Kentucky Derby for 2008.

This year we have 2 horses you should NOT bet on no matter what. The first horse you should not bet on no matter what is the favorite, Big Brown.
The second horse you should not bet on no matter what is the filly is Eight Belles.

I should have NOT listened to you!! :D:D There is your first and second place, Eight Belles was euthanized on the track after the race however.

I think next year I'll place a wager on the race and do exactly what you do not want me to do!!
 
I hate to see that for the filly, she ran such a great race. It's also clear now why the trainer didn't want to run both of his fillies in the Oaks, he knew they each had a legitimate shot to win their respective races.
 
I should have NOT listened to you!! :D:D There is your first and second place, Eight Belles was euthanized on the track after the race however.

I think next year I'll place a wager on the race and do exactly what you do not want me to do!!

This is THREE years in a row that I have sent out that email to friends (and 2 that I have posted it here) and ALL THREE YEARS the horse I said not to bet on no matter what has won the Derby. I had a VERY good day on the undercard (including a 12-1 winner outright), but the Derby is still a race I just can't wrap my handicapping brain around. The lesson, as always, is I am an idiot.

I am sick about Eight Belles, and I drank a mint julep in her honor ... she was MUCH more horse than I gave her credit for.

The only question left for Big Brown is can he get the mile and a half at the Belmont? I think we may be looking at a triple crown here folks ....
 
Last edited:
Ways To Support Nitromater

Users who are viewing this thread


Back
Top