Reiff/Frey/Reinhart/Anybody who knows anything about drag racing in the booth. Reid for Page is a lateral move at best IMO.
I agree about the lateral move. Although Reid and Page are good career play by play type hosts for auto racing, they might be comparable to a "journeyman" athlete who is good at what they do but move from team to team and don't really have a passion for any particular team. If ESPN put him back in the booth to me it would seem that they put absolutely no thought behind it and want to conveniently replace one gear for another gear to keep the machine going.
Of course it would be desirable to have a good career play by play type host who's true passion is drag racing.
Reiff is similar to Bret Kepner, Bill Stephens, or John Kernan - Great pit reporters who are good at chasing down stories. I like his tacky sense of humor too that comes through on the ESPN3 shows. But he isn't a play by play guy... well maybe he is a bit as I think him and Bob Frey do the sportsman play by play.
Reinhart is similar to Gary Gerald or Steve Evans, a great top end interview guy. Has a good knowledge base and knows the right questions to ask that all real drag fans would want to ask at the top end if they had a chance. Too bad if you're not at the track you wouldn't know it.
Frey IMO is the best fit as a replacement for PP. Massive amounts of experience with play by play live at the track, as well as recorded events such as the sportsman shows. Obviously has been exclusive to drag racing for the longest time, and there's no doubt he is passionate about the sport, yet isn't a fan boy.
I mentioned Ted Jones because he was the old play by play guy on the espn IHRA broadcasts. He hosted the Super Chevy TV shows, and as far as I can tell from briefly researching, his passion and main interest is drag racing and muscle cars. I think he is getting old though, and is more interested in retirement at this point.