Bobby Bennett
Nitro Member
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2006
- Messages
- 1,805
- Age
- 57
- Location
- Spartanburg, SC
Have you ever been in the stands of an NHRA race and REALLY observed the fans? You have the same type of people there too! There's nothing wrong with it either.Oh Kay...
A little too Hank Jr/MNFB for my taste... all I could picture in my head is a bunch of NASCAR fans, drinkin' beer, going 'Boy Howdy, looky at them thar cars run'...
d'kid
a little too hank jr/mnfb for my taste
Have you ever been in the stands of an NHRA race and REALLY observed the fans? You have the same type of people there too! There's nothing wrong with it either.
I'm just sayin.............
.
Not a drunk redneck in the bunch. In fact, don't remember anyone within our area even drinking a beer (first 4 rows at the 250 foot point)
d'kid
With the greatest respect I think this is just another product of the American Idol/America's Got Talent generation where it seems everyone with the slightest abilty suddenly appears to think that it should come easy and that its actually quite simple to write and produce something which the masses want to hear.
The writing both musically and lyrically is naive and immature in much the same way as I'd expect from a large percentage of the 16/17 year-old music and music-tech students I've taught in recent years, mainly those with little real theoretical knowledge who just "play guitar a bit".
On the engineering/production front the track doesn't hang together well at all. The drums are almost certainly samples unless they are a live recording thats been gated and effected to within an inch of their lives and are very "80's early 90's" sounding and lack the depth that would be expected with a more "live" sound which would be contemporary within the country/rock genre. The pingy snare is particularly awful. The guitar sound is crunchy enough, but again lack depth and presence and to be honest I'm not listening on studio monitors but the bass just sounds wooly and messy and is probably kept low in the mix just to try and make up for a bad initial sound.
When working with just Bass/Guit/Kit as a lineup its really important that the sound here is full and supports the vocals well in a track like this, but here the vocal is very forward in the mix, not only in terms of overall level but in terms of proximity (mainly caused by the mic'ing techique and EQ and the dryness of the vocal sound with regards to effects). This only serves to make the instruments sound even weaker and sit further back in the mix. The result is something like singing karaoke to a badly mixed backing track on your TV whilst singing straight in the listeners face.
Songwriters and record producers of the world can sleep safely, knowing that drag racers are no threat just yet... (well unless your initials are NM)
With the greatest respect I think this is just another product of the American Idol/America's Got Talent generation where it seems everyone with the slightest abilty suddenly appears to think that it should come easy and that its actually quite simple to write and produce something which the masses want to hear when in reality writing and producing should be left to those either very experienced amateurs who have both the knowledge and experience or trained professionals, who have spent years honing their skills.
The writing both musically and lyrically is naive and immature in much the same way as I'd expect from a large percentage of the 16/17 year-old music and music-tech students I've taught in recent years, mainly those with little real theoretical knowledge who just "play guitar a bit".
On the engineering/production front the track doesn't hang together well at all. The drums are almost certainly samples unless they are a live recording thats been gated and effected to within an inch of their lives and are very "80's early 90's" sounding and lack the depth that would be expected with a more "live" sound which would be contemporary within the country/rock genre. The pingy snare is particularly awful. The guitar sound is crunchy enough, but again lack depth and presence and to be honest I'm not listening on studio monitors but the bass just sounds wooly and messy and is probably kept low in the mix just to try and make up for a bad initial sound.
When working with just Bass/Guit/Kit as a lineup its really important that the sound here is full and supports the vocals well in a track like this, but here the vocal is very forward in the mix, not only in terms of overall level but in terms of proximity (mainly caused by the mic'ing techique and EQ and the dryness of the vocal sound with regards to effects). This only serves to make the instruments sound even weaker and sit further back in the mix. The result is something like singing karaoke to a badly mixed backing track on your TV whilst singing straight in the listeners face.
Songwriters and record producers of the world can sleep safely, knowing that drag racers are no threat just yet... (well unless your initials are NM)